Dear Authors,
based on the reviewers' report and my own assessment, your manuscript can be published on Solid Earth pending a request of minor revision.
Please prepare an updated revised version taking into account the comments and points raised by the two reviewers. When uploading the revised version, please also provide a rebuttal letter to explain how the reviewers' comments were addressed.

Looking forward for the revised version,

best regards

federico rossetti

Dear Authors,

Thank you for this further review. Based on the reviewers' reports and overall assessment of the review process, your manuscript can be accepted for publication, pending technical corrections as follows:
(i) In Appendix (B): delete the text "Values in bold correspond to those used for age calculations.
(1) Values not considered in the calculations due to an incorrect pattern in isotopic ratio curves (isotopic content inhomogeneity)";
(ii) in both tables shown in Appendix (B): delete the strikethrough values in both tables
(iii) format the text of the table headings.

Sincerely,

Dear Authors,
I am pleased to accept your manuscript for publication in Solid Earth pending the requested corrections.

Many thanks for choosing Solid Earth for publishing your research

best regards

Federico Rossetti