Dear authors,

Thank you for the thorough revision of your manuscript in light of reviewer's comments. I believe the manuscript now more clearly presents your results, but also opens future lines of research.
My only suggestion at this stage is a further change in the title of the manuscript, to better reflect it's current content, to "Fault interpretation in seismic reflection data: an experiment analysing the impact of conceptual model anchoring and vertical exaggeration" (or similar).

Best,
L. Perez-Diaz

Dear Authors, based on the Topical Editor's report and overall assessment of the review process, I am pleased to accept your manuscript for publication in Solid Earth, pending the technical corrections proposed by the TE.

Many thanks for choosing Solid Earth as a platform for publishing your research.

Sincerely,
Federico Rossetti