please see attached file.

Dear authors,
Thanks a lot for your hard work and I appreciate the hard decision to remove the whole study in 2D.
I trust the manuscript is very fine now, there are just few items that need to be corrected before publication:
line 28. The reference to Madjdabadi, 2016 need to be adapted to the real name. Is it Mollahasani (as indicated in line 372?). please adjust one or the other.
Line 36. reference Daley et al., 2016 misses "et al."
Line 46. reference Mateeva et al., 2014, should not be italic.
Line 46. Kuvshinov 2016 reference is missing in the reference list.
Line 54. For completeness you could add a reference about this ability to measure complex wavefield. Suggestion: Jousset, P., Currenti, G., Schwarz, B. et al. Fibre optic distributed acoustic sensing of volcanic events. Nat Commun 13, 1753 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038
Line 77. This sentence has no verb...
Line 158-159. This setence is a repetition of the sentence at lines 148. You could consider group them.
table 2. I miss this before... what is 12?
Line 201. There are 2 times a dot '.'. One is enough ;-)
Line 245. I guess this is the most important result. You could mention what is the main reason for the attenuated response of the HWC instead.
Line 302. remove the space between "on" and "e" to make the proper word "one".
Line 334. I did not find a call to the reference Brinkgreve in the text. Either introduce a reference call in the text or remove it.

Dear authors,
please consider the comments provided by the Topical Editor. After their completion, I'm looking forward to see the manuscript published.
Many thanks !, Lotte Krawczyk.

TE comments:
Dear authors,
Thanks a lot for your hard work and I appreciate the hard decision to remove the whole study in 2D.
I trust the manuscript is very fine now, there are just few items that need to be corrected before publication:
line 28. The reference to Madjdabadi, 2016 need to be adapted to the real name. Is it Mollahasani (as indicated in line 372?). please adjust one or the other.
Line 36. reference Daley et al., 2016 misses "et al."
Line 46. reference Mateeva et al., 2014, should not be italic.
Line 46. Kuvshinov 2016 reference is missing in the reference list.
Line 54. For completeness you could add a reference about this ability to measure complex wavefield. Suggestion: Jousset, P., Currenti, G., Schwarz, B. et al. Fibre optic distributed acoustic sensing of volcanic events. Nat Commun 13, 1753 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038
Line 77. This sentence has no verb...
Line 158-159. This setence is a repetition of the sentence at lines 148. You could consider group them.
table 2. I miss this before... what is 12?
Line 201. There are 2 times a dot '.'. One is enough ;-)
Line 245. I guess this is the most important result. You could mention what is the main reason for the attenuated response of the HWC instead.
Line 302. remove the space between "on" and "e" to make the proper word "one".
Line 334. I did not find a call to the reference Brinkgreve in the text. Either introduce a reference call in the text or remove it.